BlogMarket stories

How Victor Niederhoffer wiped out his fund selling naked puts in 1997

Victor Niederhoffer made 30% a year for 20 years, then lost everything selling naked puts in 1997. History does not cap the downside, and over leverage kills.

Education only, not investment advice. Figures here come from past data and backtests: illustrative, not live market data and not a performance claim.

Historically it has never happened, so the probability of such an event happening in the future is very small. If you trade based on this approach, it could bring catastrophic results. Here's the story of a hedge fund manager who lost millions because of such an approach.

A legend who broke his own rules

There is a very famous American hedge fund manager who made 30% annualised returns for 20 years. One lakh invested with this trader would have grown to almost 2 crores over that 20-year period. He is the legendary trader Victor Niederhoffer, who failed to follow his own rules.

One day, all his investors received a mail stating that the fund had lost all the investors' money and was wiped out completely: "We took risks. We were successful for a long time. This time we did not succeed, and I regret to say that all of us have suffered very large losses."

Let's explore how it all started. There is a detailed documentary about Victor, made by a Japanese firm, which is available on YouTube. Victor Niederhoffer used many quantitative techniques in his trading. He did not own a television and never relied on news.

From the 1997 Victor Niederhoffer documentary on YouTube.

Since 1982, he had earned millions of dollars for himself and his investors through Niederhoffer Global Systems, a group of hedge funds that he ran with his 20 employees. At one point he was managing more than $130 million.

In 1994, when other investors had a bad year, Niederhoffer made a 60% gain, making him the top hedge fund manager in the country. On one day in 1994, he lost 25 percent of his money on a bad trade in the Japanese yen. Within weeks, he made that money back. Such a high risk taker.

The Thai bank trade

By July 1997, Thailand had defaulted on its bonds, and many Thai banking stocks had crashed. Victor was expecting a V-shaped recovery, as he thought the Thai government would step in and stabilise things, so he invested heavily in Thai banks. But the crisis spread across Asia.

He continued to invest, but the banking stocks kept declining and his losses kept growing. Quickly it created a ripple effect, and many of the major stock markets across the world started correcting. Because of his Thai trade, his fund lost $50 million.

Naked puts on the US market

Jonathan Craig, one of the investors in Victor's fund, mentioned that to make up for the losses on the Thai bank trades, Victor started betting on the US market with naked put options, as he wasn't expecting the market to fall. He made really large bets on this trade.

He shorted put options with premiums ranging between $4 and $6, which decayed to $0.6, so at one point he was sitting on a notional profit of a few million.

By October, the Hang Seng declined steadily, which in turn affected other global markets, and by October 27, 1997, the US market had dropped significantly. The exchange even halted trading during market hours and reopened later, but the selling continued. The put option Victor sold for $4 shot up to $16, due to which his fund's NAV dropped from $70 mn to -$20 million.

Wiped out hours before the rally

Back then, this was the 12th biggest percentage loss and the 3rd biggest point loss on record. Victor's fund was sitting on a huge loss, but he was still not wiped out. The next day, October 28th 1997, the market opened gap down and continued to slide further.

This is when he started getting margin calls from his brokers. Victor couldn't arrange additional funds, and the brokers started liquidating all his open positions, which completely wiped him out. Within a few hours, the market started recovering and made a huge rally.

If this rally had come just a few hours earlier, his positions would have recovered and he would never have been wiped out. But that's how the market works: full of surprises. Always expect the unexpected.

Niederhoffer was forced to shut down his firm. He had to mortgage his house, borrow funds from friends and family, and even auction his art collection to raise money.

Niederhoffer defended his speculation in puts by saying, "I've made that trade hundreds of times in the past 15 years. I believe it's a good trade. It was a one in 2,000 shot that the market would decline like that."

True, history shows that 8 percent declines in a single day are extremely rare. But they are possible. For small investors, the lesson of history is that it doesn't tell the whole story. We can make reasonable judgments from history, but we shouldn't bet everything on it.

During this period, the journalist James K. Glassman of The Washington Post shared this view of Victor Niederhoffer:

What the story teaches

Even the best traders in the world make mistakes, but few learn from them. No matter how confident you are in any trade, never bet all your capital on one trade. When everything goes well, when you are on back-to-back winning streaks, that's when the devil comes, and you tend to ignore him by risking a huge amount.

Just because the market historically hasn't fallen beyond x% doesn't mean that's the maximum downside the market can witness. It can crash much lower than that. There is nothing certain in markets; anything could change overnight.

There is nothing certain in markets; anything could change overnight.

If you study all the market crashes that have happened in the past, one thing is common: over leverage. It kills you instantly. You can read the detailed article on this story.

I first wrote this as a thread on X. Follow me there for new ones.

  • Niederhoffer
  • naked puts
  • over leverage
  • 1997 crash
  • risk management

Kirubakaran Rajendran

Full-time algo trader, 18 years in the markets. Founder, Vecktor. I teach trading the way I work: write the rule, test it on data, then automate it.

More about me

Learn it step by step

Turn these ideas into rules you can test.