BlogMarket stories

How Ed Thorp spotted Madoff's fraud in one day

A hedge fund making 2% a month without a single losing month fooled the world for decades. Ed Thorp saw through it in a day.

Education only, not investment advice. Figures here come from past data and backtests: illustrative, not live market data and not a performance claim.

In 1990, one of the largest pension funds told the famous mathematician and legendary trader Ed Thorp: "There's this hedge fund making 2% every month for the last 10 years, without a single losing month." Ed Thorp was shocked. Is that really possible?

Harry Markopolos, a math whiz, was employed as a derivatives portfolio manager at the Rampart Investment Management Co. in Boston. He was tasked with developing a financial product that might compete with that legendary hedge fund.

Markopolos examined the hedge fund's numbers backwards and forwards, only to conclude that the returns the fund was claiming for its investors were quantifiably impossible. His employer kept telling him that he wasn't a strong enough mathematician to replicate that fund's model.

He grew frustrated and took it upon himself to launch an independent investigation into the fund's operation, with the help of a crack team of financial sleuths. He finally discovered that the hedge fund, run by Bernie Madoff, was a fraud.

Nobody was ready to listen when Harry Markopolos published a detailed article about the Madoff fraud in the year 2000 itself. Everyone was busy making money with Madoff's Ponzi scheme, and no one ever doubted it.

But it took only a single day in 1991 for the legendary math genius Edward Thorp to discover that this hedge fund giving 2% every month was a fraud. He asked the pension fund to withdraw all its investments from the fund house run by Bernie Madoff.

It took 17 years to prove

But it took more than 17 years to prove Ed Thorp was right. From the 1980s to 2008, this fund was able to give consistent returns month after month, for decades. Only by the end of 2008 did people realise it was all just a lie. Bernie Madoff was simply running a successful Ponzi scheme.

Imagine the thought process of legendary people like Ed Thorp, Warren Buffett, Ray Dalio and Peter Lynch. Almost all fund managers knew such consistent returns for decades are not possible in the markets. But large fund houses rushed to Madoff year after year out of greed.

For years Madoff was getting all the attention, but none of these legendary fund managers felt frustrated or ignored. They silently continued to focus on their work, because they knew very well that one day it was all going to end.

Most people attracted to large MTM screenshots firmly believe he or she knows some secret that makes such profits possible. No matter how much we try to warn other investors, they won't listen. So they all deserve to lose all their hard earned money eventually.

Almost all fund managers knew such consistent returns for decades are not possible in the markets.

I first wrote this as a thread on X. Follow me there for new ones.

  • Bernie Madoff
  • Ed Thorp
  • Ponzi scheme
  • Harry Markopolos

Kirubakaran Rajendran

Full-time algo trader, 18 years in the markets. Founder, Vecktor. I teach trading the way I work: write the rule, test it on data, then automate it.

More about me

Learn it step by step

Turn these ideas into rules you can test.