BlogPsychology

Why your brain keeps buying 52-week-low stocks

Anchoring and loss aversion pull us toward 52-week-low stocks. The research on momentum, and a simple backtest, show why the uncomfortable trade holds the edge.

Education only, not investment advice. Figures here come from past data and backtests: illustrative, not live market data and not a performance claim.

IRCTC stock hit a 52-week low for the first time in December 2024, at around ₹785. Since then it has kept hitting new 52-week lows, and it currently trades at ₹460. That is 40% down. But during the same period, retail investors' shareholding kept increasing. This is seen across most stocks that hit 52-week lows. So why does your brain keep choosing the 52-week-low stocks?

Anchoring: the price you saw first

Your brain cannot value a stock without a reference point. When a stock falls from ₹1200 to ₹400, your brain does not see a company worth 400 rupees. It sees a ₹1200 stock on sale at 67% off.

Suppose I ask you, "A stock trades at ₹400 today. Is that cheap?" Now suppose I tell you it hit ₹1200 last year. Then it feels cheap. Now suppose instead I tell you it was trading at ₹90 last year. Then it feels expensive. Already run up. Surely too late now.

Same ₹400. Same company. Same balance sheet. Opposite conclusion, decided entirely by which number your brain happened to see first. That is anchoring, and once you notice it, you cannot unsee it in your own decisions.

Loss aversion and averaging down

Next, the pain you get from a Rs.10k loss and the pleasure you get from a Rs.10k profit are not the same. Losing feels roughly twice as bad as winning feels good.

So when a position goes against us, selling makes the loss permanent. Holding keeps it theoretical. And averaging down actually makes us feel better, because it reduces our discomfort. This is one of the prime reasons many retail investors keep averaging down on their stocks when they keep hitting new 52-week lows.

The 52-week-low stock always comes with a beautiful story: a temporary problem, new management arriving, a sector out of favour. The 52-week-high stock has no story at all. Since price reacts first and news comes later, by the time we come to know why the stock price moved up, it is already too late for us to enter.

So we choose the stock with the better story. Buying the low feels intelligent. It feels like value investing. But buying a stock because the number is smaller than it used to be is not value investing.

What holding a loser really costs

When a stock falls 50%, it does not need 50% to bring you back. It needs 100%. When it falls 80%, it needs 400%. We cut our winners at 15% or 20% because booking a profit feels responsible. We let our losers run because selling feels like admitting we were wrong.

Money parked in a falling stock for three years waiting for a turnaround is money that was not compounding anywhere else. Your real loss is not 60%. It is 60% plus whatever the index did in those three years.

A losing position occupies your mind. Every day you check it. Every day you read one more forum post explaining why it will recover. Attention is the scarcest capital you own, and you are spending most of it on your worst asset.

Why the momentum edge survives

There are numerous research papers on momentum investing. The 1993 paper by Jegadeesh and Titman is the most famous one. They took every stock on the New York and American exchanges from 1965 to 1989 and ranked them by past return. They bought the top performers and sold the bottom performers, and they found it worked consistently.

11 years later, a second paper was published by George and Hwang. They also confirmed that a stock that hits a 52-week high has a higher probability of hitting a new 52-week high, and a stock that hits a 52-week low can keep going lower.

I used Claude AI to generate the Pine Script to backtest the same, and it proved the same.

Momentum was published in 1993. Every fund manager on earth has access to it. Any first-year analyst can code the rule in an afternoon. By every normal rule of market efficiency, an edge this famous should have been arbitraged into dust twenty years ago.

It has not been. And the reason is the whole point of this article: this strategy cannot be arbitraged away because executing it requires you to feel terrible.

This strategy cannot be arbitraged away because executing it requires you to feel terrible.

Buying a stock at its 52-week high means buying at the most expensive price it has traded at in a year. Every instinct you own screams that you are late. Your anchoring bias says it is overpriced against the number you remember. Your loss aversion says that after a run like that, the fall is coming.

Meanwhile, buying the low gives you everything comfort asks for: a discount, a story, a reason, social approval. The warm feeling of being a value investor without having done the valuation.

If a strategy ever feels completely natural, obvious and comfortable to execute, ask yourself carefully where the edge is supposed to come from. Comfortable trades are crowded trades. If a rule feels good to everybody, everybody has already done it, and the money has already been made.

The market does not pay you for being right. It pays you for being right while it feels wrong.

I first wrote this as a thread on X. Follow me there for new ones.

  • anchoring
  • loss aversion
  • momentum
  • 52 week high
  • behavioural finance

Kirubakaran Rajendran

Full-time algo trader, 18 years in the markets. Founder, Vecktor. I teach trading the way I work: write the rule, test it on data, then automate it.

More about me

Learn it step by step

Turn these ideas into rules you can test.