Why 'be greedy when others are fearful' is a myth in practice
In March 2020 I bought early, then barely added when the Sensex crashed 10 percent. Why being greedy when others are fearful is far harder than it sounds.
Education only, not investment advice. Figures here come from past data and backtests: illustrative, not live market data and not a performance claim.
Warren Buffett once said that it's wise for investors "to be fearful when others are greedy and to be greedy when others are fearful". By far, this is the biggest myth in the investing world. Let me tell you why it doesn't work that way.
When everything is going smoothly, it is much easier to think that we will not panic when there is a big decline in the market, because we tend to assume the world around us remains the same and only the stock market will decline. But that's not the case.
The whole world economy changes, and the lives of the people around us change. When everything goes well, our investment principles focus mainly on growing the portfolio, but when the market declines, we shift our investment perspective from growth to capital preservation.
What I did in March 2020
I remember buying blue chip stocks like Asian Paints, Kotak, Pidilite, Divi's Lab and Nalco on March 13, 2020, when the market corrected big time. I thought this must be the lowest point of the market, and hence I made the investments in these stocks.
But a week later, on 23 March, the Sensex crashed 10 percent, hitting its lower circuit limit. The market crashed again, and this time my perspective towards the market changed. I should have used this opportunity to buy more and invest more.
Though I was able to average out all these stocks at very attractive levels, the amount that I invested on March 23rd was very low. I did not have the courage to invest more and average it out. Why?
When the whole world is burning
Because between March 13 and March 23, 2020, the world went from bad to worse. You started hearing all the bad news, and the entire world economy came to a standstill. People around the world were dying, but a week later, people near you were dying.
You realise this is not the 2008 global financial crisis; this is a life-threatening crisis. You start comparing the Covid outbreak with the Spanish flu and the Great Depression, and you think even our market can crash 89% like it did in 1929. You imagine all the worst-case scenarios.
When the whole world is burning down, you just want to save what you have. You just want to protect your family. No amount of Excel analysis or investing formulas will help you out.
When the whole world is burning down, you just want to save what you have.
We can study all the historical charts and do every type of investment model analysis, but we can't measure human emotions when people are thrown into adverse moments. I have done 100s of research studies on trading and investing, and I have multiple systems in place to handle volatility, but this is the message I sent to my HDFC relationship manager, where I had just a few lakhs in an FD. Look how scared I was. In hindsight, I can now think I should have withdrawn this FD and invested in the markets, but at that time I was a totally different person.
Read history, not forecasts
There is no way one can predict the future. No amount of detailed study of forecasts can help you take the right decision when the time arrives. Instead of trying to create models or forecasts for investing and trading, read more about history.
Try to learn how people reacted during adverse times. Such insights would greatly help you build the right psychology to handle panic situations. The Great Depression: A Diary is one such book; it gives you a detailed account of how people behaved during the 1929 crash.
It's a reminder that investing and trading are not as easy as they sound. With the rise of technology and AI/ML, no matter what, human emotions will remain the same as always. However, no matter what the crisis is, "this too shall pass" applies to every aspect of our life.
I first wrote this as a thread on X. Follow me there for new ones.