Why every trade you enter loses money: entry vs exit and news trading
A day in the life of a news-driven trader shows why greed, not fear, blows accounts, and why the payoff and the exit matter more than the entry.
Education only, not investment advice. Figures here come from past data and backtests: illustrative, not live market data and not a performance claim.
“Whenever I enter a trade, I end up losing money. Should I stop trading and start investing?” This question comes to our minds very often during our early phase. Here is what we are doing wrong, and how to correct it.
This question often creeps in because most of you give the utmost importance to the entry and are least bothered about the exit. Let's see how a typical trader starts his day.
A typical news trader's day
He first scans the newspaper and looks for the hot topic of the moment. He sees a news item like this: “AGR verdict: Supreme Court to hear telcos' review pleas in closed chamber today. Telecom companies, who are looking at a payout of Rs 92,000 crore.”
Then he decides: OK, today is going to be the day for telecom sector stocks. Any of these stocks can move violently, and we can get in quickly when it moves and make some quick money. He adds these stocks to his watchlist and keeps staring at it like an eagle, waiting for some move.
But once the market opens, the movement he expected in the stocks isn't happening. The stock is moving in a tight range, neither in an uptrend nor in a downtrend. He wanted to get in and waited for hours, but he is still unsure which way the stock will move.
He makes his own decision. He thinks this stock might move up more, so he finally buys it. And waits. Still not much movement. He waits again. He keeps staring at the MTM screen. The P&L is oscillating between plus and minus. He is nervous, because he bought a huge quantity of Airtel. He is so sure that the stock will definitely move up that all he thinks about now is: how much am I going to make in this trade?
After waiting for some time, he wants some reassurance that he is right. So he logs into Twitter and checks what others are saying about his stock. He searches for the stock's name, and he is happy that others are also bullish on it, as many people have tweeted that this stock will move like a rocket: OI added, volume increased, blah blah.
Now he is even more confident, so he decides to add to his position. What could go wrong, when the entire world thinks my stock is going to move up? So he adds a much bigger position, and finally he is happy when he sees those upticks on the chart. With each 1 rupee move, he is making 1000s of rupees in profit. A few minutes down the line, he has already made 3 months of his salary as profit in just one trade.
Why winning streaks are dangerous
He is a lot more confident now. He thinks he has gained more knowledge and that the profits he is making come purely from his skill, whereas in reality it is just a random outcome. But he repeats the same mistake, pumps in more capital later and blows his account, only to realise that trading is simple but not easy. It's greed that kills a trader, not fear. Winning streaks are more brutal, so be careful.
It's greed that kills a trader, not fear.
It goes like this. The more successful you are at something, the more convinced you become that you're doing it right. The more convinced you are that you're doing it right, the less open you are to change. The less open you are to change, the more likely you are to fail one day.
Look at the payoff, not the probability
If you see a trade that shows a 90% chance it will go up and a 10% chance it will go down, we are more likely to go long in this trade.
But if I say there's a 90% chance it will move up 5% and a 10% chance it can go down 90%, what will you do? We are more likely to avoid this trade, since the payoff is bad.
As Nassim Taleb clearly explained in his book Fooled by Randomness, don't just go by the probability of the loss. Check the final payoff and then decide on the trade.
Instead of asking “How much am I going to make in this trade?”, if he had asked “How much am I going to lose in this trade?”, he would have realised the risk in the trade and taken his position accordingly.
Losses are part of the business
Always be a rule-based trader, not a news-based trader. When you trade on random news, your trade results will also be random in nature. Some days you make profits, and many days you keep losing.
You can't make money without losing some. Imagine you run a small restaurant that sells only biriyani. Some days it sells like hot cakes, and all your biriyani is sold out in a few hours. And some days there are still some leftovers. What do you do? Do you feel bad?
You accept the fact that some days there will always be leftovers. You accept that loss. You don't crib, because that's how business works. Then why are you not able to accept a loss in trading? Losses in trading are part of the business. Accept them.
You enter an intraday trade, and if it doesn't give you a profit, you convert it into a positional trade. If the positional trade doesn't give you a profit in a few days, you convert it into a long-term trade. This is how traders go bust. Don't do that. If it's an intraday trade, it has to be closed before 3:20 PM. Just because it's not making a profit for you, don't convert it.
Follow a trading system, and learn about position sizing to understand how much to risk on each trade. Executing your trades flawlessly as per your trading plan is the only holy grail in the markets. If you do not have a trading plan, create one first.
I first wrote this as a thread on X. Follow me there for new ones.