BlogPsychology

Why discretionary trading is hard: a Bank Nifty trade story

After a long time trading only rules, I took a discretionary Bank Nifty trade, ignored my stop loss and kept adding to a losing position.

Education only, not investment advice. Figures here come from past data and backtests: illustrative, not live market data and not a performance claim.

In general, making money from trading is harder than in any other business, and I believe discretionary trading is even harder. Why do so many beginners go bust within 90 days of their trading career? Here's why discretionary trading is hard.

Every trader starts out as a discretionary trader. They trade based on how they feel about the markets, and they look at how the market behaved in the recent past, such as how it moved in the last week. If the market moved up over the last month and suddenly starts dropping, they tend to think it is now trading at a cheaper price. They buy into it, only to regret it later when the market keeps falling every day.

Why I moved to rules

I started as a discretionary trader and later moved to system-based trading. It's not about the profits; it's more about how comfortable I am with system-based trading. When you trade based on certain rules, it gives you a lot of freedom. Your mind doesn't constantly ask, "What's next?" You know clearly when to enter, where to exit, what your stop loss should be before you even get into the trade, and how much is too much (position sizing). Everything is in your control except the profits.

But when you trade on discretion, you always feel that you are under the market's control. It had been a long time since I took a discretionary trade, so recently I wanted to try one to know how it feels. I took this long trade in Bank Nifty futures on 10 Nov.

The trade

My analysis said that since Sep 2021 the market had rallied really well, from 37000 to almost 42000 levels: a 5000 point rally. Now the market had cooled off and given a good correction of 3000 points, so I thought it was good to buy. I went long Bank Nifty futures around 39150.

Instead of a fixed stop loss of 50 or 100 points, I checked the next support, which was at 38500, and decided to keep my stop loss there. But deep in my mind, I was convinced the market was going to bounce back. I never thought it might come down near my stop loss level.

Averaging down instead of exiting

The market always surprises you. The next day it was trading below my stop loss level of 38500. Now I had two choices: accept the stop loss and get out, or buy more and average it out. I decided to do the latter. If I could buy at 39150 with conviction, I should be able to buy more at 38500 instead of getting out, because the market might bounce back any time soon. Why should I exit now and lose the opportunity?

I bought one more lot around 38500, my old stop loss level. I ignored my stop loss because I thought the market had given me an opportunity to add more at lower levels. After I bought, the market rallied and moved back to 39000 levels. This increased my conviction.

I told myself, "See how genius I am." If I had followed my stop loss and exited at 38500, I would have made a loss. Instead, by buying one more lot, I was able to average down my buy price and make good profits.

But the market started drifting lower again from 16 Nov 2021. Bank Nifty fell more than 500 points and came back to 38500 levels. The market kept proving me wrong and showing that the trend was bearish, but I kept ignoring it. I wanted confirmation from other experts.

To see what people think about Bank Nifty, we usually check Twitter. And your eyes will only look for the people shouting "buy, buy, buy".

You went long, and you feel a bit relaxed when others are also bullish. There will be another set of traders who think the market is bearish and the trend is down, but your mind will ignore them and think they are wrong. After checking Twitter, I was convinced the market could bounce back any time.

I added one more lot around 38000. The stop loss I had in mind when I took the trade was gone, because now my conviction was even stronger than before: many banking stocks had corrected, and the market had also corrected 4000 points. It couldn't go down any further.

Where most beginners get stuck

Again, the market keeps surprising you. It has now broken its support zone of 38000 and is trading much lower, and my losses keep increasing. As a normal discretionary trader, this is where most beginners get stuck.

They start the trade with one analysis, and as the market keeps moving, their decision keeps changing. We can't stick to the trade; our mind won't allow us to take that loss. So we always hope the market will reverse. But it won't happen until you give up.

The moment you decide, "Oh, this is enough, let me accept the loss and move on", it will be too late. You will have lost considerable capital, and it might take you a long time to come back.

You need to decide what kind of person you are. If you are very disciplined, can control your emotions when a trade goes against you and think you can handle discretionary trading with ease, then go for it. Otherwise, rule-based trading is the only way to avoid irrational decisions.

Everything is in your control except the profits.

You can read the full story in my blog post on discretionary trading.

I first wrote this as a thread on X. Follow me there for new ones.

  • discretionary trading
  • stop loss
  • averaging down
  • Bank Nifty

Kirubakaran Rajendran

Full-time algo trader, 18 years in the markets. Founder, Vecktor. I teach trading the way I work: write the rule, test it on data, then automate it.

More about me

Learn it step by step

Turn these ideas into rules you can test.