BlogPsychology

Position sizing: the 2% rule and Milo's calf

Your position size, not the price move, is what makes you panic. Here is a simple 2% risk formula, and why size should grow like Milo's calf.

Education only, not investment advice. Figures here come from past data and backtests: illustrative, not live market data and not a performance claim.

Trading is the only profession where you can see doctors, engineers and many other successful professionals try their luck with the stock market. These people excel in their own fields but struggle a lot when it comes to trading.

Unfortunately, everybody believes that a successful trader always has a secret technical skill. But the truth is that technical skill is the least important factor in becoming a superstar trader. Then what separates a great trader from the group of average traders? It's their emotion.

How you should think about a trade

This is how most traders think: they first think about the entry point. At which price should I buy? At which level should I enter? At which point should I get into a trade?

But this is how you must think to be a profitable trader. You have to adopt a trading strategy that suits your psychology, assign trade management rules, and keep position sizing and money management rules.

What really made Vicky panic

One of the main reasons people lose money in the stock market is their position size. For example, Vicky starts trading with a capital of Rs. 1,00,000. He finds a trading opportunity and buys SpiceJet shares at Rs. 100. At the most, he can buy 1000 shares of SpiceJet.

Now if the stock rises to 110 in a few days, he will gain 10 × 1000 = 10,000. That is 10% of his capital. He sells all his 1000 shares, and making 10% returns in a short span makes him happier and makes him want to try his luck again.

What if he buys 1000 shares at 100 again and the stock goes down to 90? He will lose 10% of his capital in a short span of time. He may hold the stock as it continues to slide: 90, 85, 80. He panics and sells all his shares at 80, losing 20% of his capital.

What made Vicky panic? SpiceJet stock falling from 100 to 80? No. The 1000 shares that he bought made him panic.

Imagine if he had 100 shares. The stock falling from 100 to 80 results in a 2000 loss, which is just 2% of his capital. In this situation, Vicky might be in a better position to make wise decisions.

How many shares to buy

So next time, follow these rules to know how many shares you need to buy:

  • A. Capital: Rs. 10,000
  • B. Entry price of your stock: Rs. 100
  • C. Stop loss: Rs. 90
  • D. Risk: Rs. 10
  • E. We should risk only 2% of capital: 2% of 10,000 = Rs. 200
  • F. Number of shares: Rs. 200 / risk (formula = E / D)

So when you buy 20 shares, if the trade goes against us and hits the stop loss, we will lose 20 × 10 = Rs. 200 only, which is just 2% of the capital.

Milo and the calf

Many traders have a trading psychology issue when they scale up their trading size. I have read a wonderful story which relates very much to trading. Listen up.

Meet Milo of Croton, the great ancient Greek Olympian. He was the greatest and strongest wrestler of Greece. He won six consecutive Olympic medals! Remember what Usain Bolt said? Win three and become immortal? Imagine six!

How did he become so strong? He started his training by lifting a newborn calf. Hah! So easy peasy. I can lift a calf. You too can lift a calf. What's the point in lifting a tiny calf? Huh.

His competitors attempted to lift an adult bull instead. Yo. And they all laughed off the calf lifting. Who does that! Stupid Milo. Huh.

Milo carried the calf daily, all the time. The calf grew slowly and so did Milo's strength. And ultimately Milo could lift a bull effortlessly. But his smart competitors were still trying to lift the bull. Sometimes succeeding, maybe, but not excelling like Milo. Smart Milo.

Learn from Milo. Buy a calf. Lift it daily, rather than lifting a bull.

If someone is trading with 50 lots and, after making more profit over a period, decides to increase his size from 50 to 100, he will definitely have a tough time. Remember, nothing has changed here. All his trading rules are the same, but he would still struggle to trade.

It is because he is used to 50 lots. When he trades with 50 lots, he is used to the negative MTM, the daily losses, the max losses and so on. As he traded with that fixed size for a longer period, he got used to these daily fluctuations in his account.

Now, after seeing good profits, if he decided to double the size, he would not be able to handle it efficiently. So after some losses he would go back to the same old position size of 50 lots, and he would keep trying to increase it to 100, but he would fail every time.

Instead, he has to increase his position size gradually rather than doubling it in one go. That's why it is advised to trade based on a risk % of capital rather than a fixed size, which will help us reduce drawdowns.

Learn from Milo. Buy a calf. Lift it daily, rather than lifting a bull.

Happy trading! You can read the complete article.

I first wrote this as a thread on X. Follow me there for new ones.

  • position sizing
  • 2% rule
  • risk management
  • scaling up
  • Milo of Croton

Kirubakaran Rajendran

Full-time algo trader, 18 years in the markets. Founder, Vecktor. I teach trading the way I work: write the rule, test it on data, then automate it.

More about me

Learn it step by step

Turn these ideas into rules you can test.