Momentum investing the right way and the Nifty200 Momentum 30 index
Good momentum investing weighs a stock's path as well as its gain. Here is how the Nifty200 Momentum 30 index does that, and how option traders use it.
Education only, not investment advice. Figures here come from past data and backtests: illustrative, not live market data and not a performance claim.
If you put a frog in boiling water, it immediately jumps out. However, if you place the frog in normal water and then start boiling it slowly, the frog won't react immediately. Instead, it tries to adapt to the environment. By the time it realises that it is sitting in boiling water, it is too late, and eventually it gets cooked to death. Most of us are familiar with this story. Momentum trading is all about the frog in the hot water.
When you read news about a stock that is going to help the company achieve super profits (hot water), people flock together and buy the stock, making the price hit upper circuits back to back within a few days. However, we tend to ignore news about stocks that won't have any significant impact on growth in the near future (normal water). But such stocks slowly react to this lower-impact news and start moving up gradually (boiling water).
This is when people notice that the stock has gained momentum, and they get on this moving train, expecting it to move faster in the coming days so that they can get off a few stations down the line with handsome profits.
What momentum trading is
The momentum strategy is based on the idea that if there is enough force behind a price move, it will continue to move in the same direction. Momentum trading is about identifying stocks that are already on the move, rather than predicting their future value.
The main reason momentum trading gained so much traction is its ease of execution. You don't need to spend much time analysing and executing; all you have to do is spend 10 to 15 mins of your time every weekend. That helps in choosing the top N momentum stocks. You invest in them and rebalance every week or month by repeating the same method: keep the top momentum stocks and exit the bottom momentum stocks from the list. That's the whole idea.
The right way: add volatility
Most momentum traders simply follow a relative strength method: they check how much a stock has gained over N periods, then simply invest and rebalance. They don't consider the most important factor, which is volatility.
Wesley Gray, PhD explained it well in a subtle way. In the graph below, consider Stock A and Stock B, which both gained similar traction. Stock A moved slowly and gradually, while Stock B was dull most of the time but suddenly picked up momentum.
Normal momentum traders would pick both stocks based on relative strength. However, Stock A (Good) should be chosen over Stock B (Bad), since on a volatility-adjusted basis, Stock A (Good) is the right choice.
So don't simply go by the strength of the stock; consider the path of the stock as well. Check whether the stock's reaction was due to hot water, or whether it was a late reaction to normal water that turned into boiling water.
Who invented momentum trading
Jegadeesh and Titman published a research paper in 1993 about the significance of the momentum-based approach and how it beats the benchmark index to a great extent. After that, many CTAs and fund managers started following momentum-based approaches.
In fact, multiple other authors had been talking about momentum trading even from 1937. In India, momentum-based trading gained traction only during the 2017 bull run, when a few traders started talking about it.
Momentum index funds and ETFs
There are many smallcases and traders who actively follow momentum trading with baskets of Nifty 200 stocks. If it's working well, that's good. You should continue doing it.
However, people who are primarily into option trading and want to get into momentum trading can opt for momentum index funds or ETFs. The Nifty200 Momentum 30 Index tracks the performance of the top 30 companies based on their normalised momentum score.
The normalised momentum score for each company is determined from its 6-month and 12-month price returns, adjusted for its daily price volatility. So it doesn't consider only the price, like most momentum smallcases; it also considers the volatility factor.
The Nifty200 Momentum 30 Index has outperformed since inception, with an 18.6% CAGR against 12.7% for the Nifty 200. The drawdown is almost similar for the momentum index and the Nifty 200, but in terms of returns the momentum index has outperformed significantly.
People who want to take advantage of this momentum index can invest in any of the index funds or ETFs listed below. The expense ratios are relatively low. Out of all the funds, the UTI Nifty 200 Momentum 30 index fund has a good AUM with a decent expense ratio.
Pledge it for option selling margin
The best thing is that, as an option trader, instead of keeping your cash idle or investing in Nifty BeES, you can buy this momentum index fund, pledge it and continue to trade your option selling system. Zerodha users can invest in the UTI Momentum index fund, where the haircut is only 7.5%.
If you invest 1 lakh, you can get margin of up to Rs. 92,500. So you end up getting good margin plus the appreciation of the underlying asset, and you are indirectly participating in momentum trading without the need for any weekend analysis.
Momentum trading is all about the frog in the hot water.
Here's the detailed video on YouTube and the article on the best way to do momentum trading in India.
I first wrote this as a thread on X. Follow me there for new ones.