Daily vs weekly vs monthly SIP: 44 years of Sensex data
I tested every SIP frequency on Sensex data since 1979. Apart from daily, the results barely differ. What matters is the discipline to keep going.
Education only, not investment advice. Figures here come from past data and backtests: illustrative, not live market data and not a performance claim.
Indian mutual funds currently have about 93.4 million SIP accounts. What is the ideal frequency for SIP investment: daily, weekly, monthly, quarterly, half yearly or yearly? Which type of SIP generates higher returns? Let's analyse this with the last 40+ years of data.
Monthly SIP since 1979
I considered a Sensex index SIP from its beginning in April 1979 to date. If a monthly SIP of ₹10,000 had been done over these 44 years, the total invested amount would have been 54 lakh and the total fund value would have been around 46 crore.
Even though it created significant wealth in the long run, it's not as easy as it looks. At the peak of 2008, the 35 lakh invested through the SIP had grown to 11.5 crore, but by the end of 2008, more than 50% of the fund value was eroded and it was down to 5 crore.
Imagine you were 30 when you started your SIP in 1979, planning to retire after 30 years. By 2009 you would have planned to withdraw the 30 years of life savings you had put into the SIP, only to realise later that some big corporates like Lehman had screwed up. At 60, at the time of retirement, you lose 50% of your investment value.
This is hard hitting. You can never time the market; nobody knows what your SIP will turn into when you need it the most. But the best part is that in spite of such a crash, you still made reasonable returns.
If you started your SIP during 2008, you would still have made much higher returns if you kept doing the SIP continuously. After the 50% fall, it appreciated almost 8 times: from a 5 crore fund value, it grew to a 45 crore fund value in the next 16 years.
Daily, weekly and longer frequencies
Daily: If someone had done the SIP daily, investing ₹500 a day instead of ₹10,000 a month, their overall invested value would be about 52 lakh and the fund value would have been 38 crore.
Weekly: If someone had done the SIP weekly, investing ₹2,500 a week instead of ₹10,000 a month, their overall invested value would be about 58 lakh and the fund value would have been 49 crore.
Quarterly: If someone had done the SIP quarterly, investing ₹30,000 every quarter instead of ₹10,000 a month, their overall invested value would be about 54 lakh and the fund value would have been 45 crore.
Half yearly: If someone had done the SIP half yearly, investing ₹60,000 once every 6 months instead of ₹10,000 a month, their overall invested value would be about 55 lakh and the fund value would have been 46 crore.
Yearly: If someone had done the SIP yearly, investing ₹1,20,000 once a year instead of ₹10,000 a month, their overall invested value would be about 55 lakh and the fund value would have been 45 crore.
Consistency matters more than frequency
So if we compare daily vs weekly vs monthly vs quarterly vs half yearly vs yearly, in the long run, except for the daily time frame, nothing makes any difference. The returns are more or less the same. What matters is consistency: your discipline to stick to your SIP and not stop it.
To do this analysis, we need historical data plus coding knowledge. But I used TradingView historical data and ChatGPT to generate the necessary Pine Script code. This made the job much easier, and the whole analysis was done in a few minutes.
Adjusting for inflation
A ₹10,000 SIP might look normal now, but considering inflation over the last 44 years, ₹10,000 back in the 1980s is equal to 2.4 lakh today, which is huge considering the average household income then. So let's reduce the monthly SIP from ₹10,000 to ₹500, which is today's ₹10,000.
If someone had invested just ₹500 every month in a Sensex SIP (an index fund) from 1980 to date, the invested amount would have been 2.72 lakh, whereas the fund value would have been 2.3 crore, which is still a significant amount in today's value.
Wealth creation is a slow and simple process, so do not complicate it. It takes decades to build generational wealth. It doesn't matter how much you earn; start investing, even if it's only a little. Remember, we don't have to be smarter than the rest. We have to be more disciplined than the rest.
What matters is consistency: your discipline to stick to your SIP and not stop it.
I first wrote this as a thread on X. Follow me there for new ones.