BlogPsychology

Confirmation, rationalisation and bandwagon bias in trading

How confirmation bias, post-trade rationalisation and the bandwagon effect show up while you trade, and what to do about each one.

Education only, not investment advice. Figures here come from past data and backtests: illustrative, not live market data and not a performance claim.

If you are someone who spends more time analysing markets while trading, then this is for you. Certain traders create their own bullish or bearish view in their mind and then seek confirmation for their trades. This is called confirmation bias.

Confirmation bias

We do not like people or information that contradict our thoughts. We like them when they confirm what we think. Hence, we tend to place more weight on information that confirms our trade position. For example, say you think the market is bullish and want to take a long position.

  • Next, a new bullish bar prints on the chart. You think, "Yes, my bullish proposition is still valid" (even though this bullish bar has a smaller range).
  • A bearish bar prints. But you think, "This bar lacks momentum" (because you already firmly believe the market is bullish).
  • One more bearish bar follows, pushing against a support level. But you think, "The support level is holding. Bullishness confirmed. Buy more!" (even though this bar closed below the support level with clear momentum).

Because we are looking for confirmation, we lose sight of what the market is showing us. When you think that everything is confirming your market view, think again. Look for reasons against taking a trade, not for it. You need to adapt to market movements.

Post-trade rationalisation

After getting into a trade, we tend to rationalise it and prove that our trade is right. The reason is that we spend a significant amount of time and effort on research before placing a trade, so we do not want to admit that we placed it with bad judgement.

You waited patiently and observed intently. You refrained from taking sub-optimal trades, waiting for the one perfect trade that would make your day. It arrived, and you took it without hesitation. But after you got into the position, post-purchase rationalisation crept in.

You had put considerable effort into finding this one good trade, so you refused to accept that it might be a losing trade. You rationalised that the position was still good despite several warning signs. As a result, you gave up chances to exit with a small gain.

The market plummeted, and a small gain became a substantial loss. Don't try to rationalise your trade while you are in it. You should have already justified your trade before you entered. This is why they say, "Plan your trade and trade your plan."

Don't try to rationalise your trade while you are in it.

Bandwagon bias

And then there is another set of traders. We take certain trades because everyone else seems to be doing it, even when there are no good reasons for doing so.

For example, you heard everyone saying that the bull market would stop soon. The news, gurus and forums were all bursting with negativity. You looked at your charts with your technical analysis tools and found nothing bearish. You looked at more charts and found some bullish clues.

But because everyone was saying that the bull market would come to an end, you sold all your long positions. Whether the market went on to rise or fall, you had already given in to the bandwagon bias, because you followed the herd instead of your own analysis.

The best traders are often lonely, because they listen to their own analysis and ignore the voices of the masses. But don't adopt a contrarian mindset and always go against the herd either. The crowd might be right, or wrong. But you are probably wrong when you think that something is right only because everyone seems to say so.

These are some points I read somewhere on Quora and wanted to share here. These psychological aspects always play on your mind when you are trading. If you handle them well, half the battle is won.

I first wrote this as a thread on X. Follow me there for new ones.

  • confirmation bias
  • trading psychology
  • bandwagon bias
  • rationalisation

Kirubakaran Rajendran

Full-time algo trader, 18 years in the markets. Founder, Vecktor. I teach trading the way I work: write the rule, test it on data, then automate it.

More about me

Learn it step by step

Turn these ideas into rules you can test.