BlogPsychology

Algo trading is not a money machine: living with drawdowns

Algo returns are not a straight line. Bill Dunn and Andrea Unger show that the discipline to sit through deep drawdowns separates winners from losers.

Education only, not investment advice. Figures here come from past data and backtests: illustrative, not live market data and not a performance claim.

When people talk about automated trading systems, this is what comes to mind for most beginners who want to get into it. Many think it's a plug and play system: you deposit the funds, link your account to the algo, and it trades for you and makes money every month.

No! It doesn't work like that. Algo trading is not a money making machine and it doesn't remove emotions. Whether it's auto trading or manual trading, emotions will always be there when it comes to trading. We can't ignore them.

This is the expectation most people have when they start with an automated trading system: they want their capital to appreciate month on month, year on year, with linear returns like these.

Drawdowns are part of the game

But in reality it's different. You need to live with drawdowns most of the time. Here's the live performance of hedge fund manager Bill Dunn. In the last 50 years of his live track record, he has witnessed 13 drawdowns greater than -25% and years of underperformance.

In years like 2008 he lost -63%. Most people would not be able to handle these, especially the 63% drawdown. Who can handle losing half of their account? Drawdowns are simply part of the trading game. That's how it works.

How a champion handles drawdowns

Most people only notice the outstanding returns; no one sees what one has to go through to achieve them. Andrea Unger, one of the best traders and a three time winner of the world championship trading contest, shared the following equity curves.

What is fascinating is that in each of those years he had at least one drawdown approaching 50% (in his best year, 2008, it looks like he had a 75% drawdown). But he ended each year with over 100% return (115%, 240%, 672%).

Performance like this makes Andrea Unger one of the best traders in the world, mainly because of his ability to withstand drawdowns. Most people would have given up during one of the drawdowns. But not Andrea. He had a solid trading method, and he knew that he would recover from those drawdowns. And each of those years, he won the contest!

Algo trading, or automated trading, is all about being disciplined with your investment and sticking to the rules no matter what. That's what separates winners from losers.

Drawdowns are simply part of the trading game.

I first wrote this as a thread on X. Follow me there for new ones.

  • algo trading myths
  • drawdown
  • bill dunn
  • andrea unger
  • discipline

Kirubakaran Rajendran

Full-time algo trader, 18 years in the markets. Founder, Vecktor. I teach trading the way I work: write the rule, test it on data, then automate it.

More about me

Learn it step by step

Turn these ideas into rules you can test.