BlogOptions

The 0DTE edge is fading: intraday vs overnight straddles

6 years of NIFTY data on short straddles: since 2025, the overnight 1DTE trade has beaten the 0DTE intraday trade, with smaller drawdowns.

Education only, not investment advice. Figures here come from past data and backtests: illustrative, not live market data and not a performance claim.

The 0DTE edge is slowly fading away. I ran a detailed analysis of 6 years of historical data to study what has changed recently, and why many intraday option sellers are facing the heat. Here's the study.

Everyone "knows" holding a short straddle overnight is riskier than intraday. I tested 6 years of NIFTY historical data, and the data says the opposite. The 0DTE intraday edge is dying, and overnight sellers are quietly getting paid.

I studied two things: short straddle movement on a positional basis versus an intraday basis.

  • Intraday: sell the ATM straddle at 9:20 AM, exit at 3:25 PM.
  • Positional: sell the ATM straddle at 3:25 PM, exit at 9:20 AM the next day.

Both use the same strike.

From 2021 to mid-2025, intraday clearly outperformed positional. But look at the right edge of the chart. From 2025 onwards, after most of the other weekly expiries were removed, the positional overnight straddle performed better than intraday.

The two purest expiry trades

Then I isolated the two purest expiry trades:

  • 0DTE intraday: expiry day, 9:20 to 3:25.
  • 1DTE positional: the day before expiry at 3:25 to expiry day at 9:20.

0DTE was ahead till early 2023. Since then, it has gone sideways to down, with violent 500 to 700 point drawdowns, while the 1DTE overnight system compounded steadily.

If we check the overall yearly performance, 2024 was exceptional for intraday players, but 2025 and 2026 so far have been exceptionally good for overnight option sellers compared with intraday.

Drawdowns tell the same story

Drawdowns are more brutal with intraday than with positional. From 2025, the overnight 1DTE short straddle faced lower drawdowns than the 0DTE intraday short straddle.

Even if I compare the drawdowns of short straddles on all days instead of only 1DTE and 0DTE, intraday drawdowns are still higher than positional from 2025 onwards.

From 2025, the regime slowly shifted. For the risk option sellers take, overnight players are rewarded more than intraday players. The intraday risk premium got arbitraged flat; the overnight one survived because fewer people are willing to hold it.

You now get paid for the risk others refuse to carry, and paid nothing for the risk everyone is happy to take.

You now get paid for the risk others refuse to carry, and paid nothing for the risk everyone is happy to take.

I first wrote this as a thread on X. Follow me there for new ones.

  • 0dte
  • 1dte
  • overnight straddle
  • option selling

Kirubakaran Rajendran

Full-time algo trader, 18 years in the markets. Founder, Vecktor. I teach trading the way I work: write the rule, test it on data, then automate it.

More about me

Learn it step by step

Turn these ideas into rules you can test.