High risk is not high returns: volatility drag explained
Higher average returns can hide a shrinking account. Three trading systems with the same logic show how volatility drag turns more risk into less money.
Education only, not investment advice. Figures here come from past data and backtests: illustrative, not live market data and not a performance claim.
Many of us think that high risk will always end in high returns. Is it really true? If you are running a trading system that makes average returns with minimal risk, and you are now thinking of increasing the risk to make higher returns, this article might help you.
Three systems, same logic
Let's assume three different trading systems. We always give importance to the average returns made over the years. The chart below shows the average returns of three trading systems over the last 10 years. Which one would you go for? Most will obviously opt for System C.
Now let us dig deep. All three trading systems use the same logic; we are just increasing the risk 3 or 4 times.
- System A: up 30% one year, down -15% the next, repeated for 10 years
- System B: up 90% one year, down -45% the next
- System C: up 120% one year, down -60% the next
If you had invested Rs. 1 lakh in System A in 2013 and continued for the next 10 years, your 1 lakh would have grown to Rs. 1,64,745. Your overall return would be 65% in ten years.
Why +50% then -50% is a loss
As system traders, most of us would think the risk is only -15% with System A, so if we could increase the risk 3 or 4 times, we could make huge returns. But one important factor that we fail to understand is that high risk is not equal to high returns.
A +50% return followed by a -50% loss is not equal to 0%. You have 1 lakh capital, and you make 50% returns. Now your capital is Rs. 1,50,000. Then you make a -50% loss on Rs. 1,50,000, so you end up with Rs. 75,000.
So by making +50% and -50%, you are actually losing -25% of your capital. That's why volatility is a very important factor to consider when developing a trading system. Many of us compromise on volatility to make higher returns.
So by making +50% and -50%, you are actually losing -25% of your capital.
What more risk does over 10 years
Considering this, if you had increased the risk three times and traded System A, after 10 years the average yearly return might be 23%, whereas your overall return for ten years is only 25%: your 1 lakh initial capital would end up at Rs. 1,24,618.
Similarly, if you had increased the risk 4 times, System C's average returns over 10 years might look attractive, but your actual returns would be negative: your 1 lakh initial capital would end up at Rs. 52,773. Almost 50% of your capital is wiped out.
This is volatility drag
- System A, with minimal returns and risk, performs best in the long run.
- System B, with higher average returns than System A, was not able to generate higher returns in the long run.
- System C loses money in spite of having higher average returns.
This is known as volatility drag.
Deciding which mutual funds to invest in, or which trading system to follow, based on average returns will give us the wrong picture. Higher risk will not always end in higher returns. If you are a system trader trying to increase your risk to generate higher returns, be careful.
Here's the detailed blog post on whether high risk can give high returns.
I first wrote this as a thread on X. Follow me there for new ones.