A checklist for designing a trading strategy
What I keep in mind when designing a trading or investing strategy, from realistic return expectations to scoring your discipline before you add capital.
Education only, not investment advice. Figures here come from past data and backtests: illustrative, not live market data and not a performance claim.
When you are designing a trading or investing strategy, here is a list of things you need to keep in mind.
Set realistic return expectations
You need to set realistic return expectations. Making 100% or 200% year on year is not possible at all. Do not get fooled by MTM screenshots, and do not just go by absolute numbers. The average returns of the prominent traders and investors are just 20% to 30%.
Know what you don't know
In the Mahabharata, Duryodhana won the bet because he knew that he didn't know how to gamble, so he used his uncle to play the game. Dharma lost the bet because he didn't know how to play the game. This is so true of trading as well.
Being good at equity trading doesn't mean you can trade commodities or crypto well. They require altogether different market knowledge. If you do not have the required skill set, outsource it to a skilled person who can do that task for you.
Find what suits you
Don't just look at the overall profitability of a trading system. Those high returns can't be achieved if you cannot sustain the drawdown period. If you can't stick to a system, there is no use even if you have the most profitable system.
Trend following systems and option buying systems will be in drawdown most of the time. Just a few trades are enough to overcome the drawdown and get back to the profitable zone. But how many of us can handle such long periods with no income? Will it suit you?
So find out how many days a system goes underwater, and calculate this ratio: the total number of trading days divided by the total number of drawdown days. The higher the ratio, the better.
Define, backtest and optimise
Define. Thanks to no-code platforms like Stockmock, you can define your rules clearly. You should know clearly what you are going to trade, and your target, stop loss, entry and exit rules. You cannot simply trade head and shoulders or cup and saucer patterns, because they cannot be quantified.
Only when your trading rules can be quantified can they be backtested. Visual chart patterns were developed years ago, before the computer era, and there is a research paper on SSRN which found that such well-known chart patterns aren't profitable at all.
These are the three most important elements in trading. Many traders lack a proper trading strategy. Even if they have one, they lack the discipline to stick to the system, and they are unable to stick to it because they do not know “how much is too much”.
Backtest. Winning accuracy is the least important factor in a trading system. The famous Turtle Trader Richard Dennis traded with less than 30% winning accuracy and was still able to make millions, because the profits he made on winning trades were much higher than the losses on losing trades.
Optimise. It's a never-ending cycle. You can't find a perfect system that works in all types of markets. It never exists. So don't fine-tune or add multiple parameters in the backtest. Keep it simple. If you can't explain your trading rules in two lines, they are not robust.
Forward test, then go live
Forward test. Do not just paper trade: it's a waste of time. Instead, test your strategy in live markets with one or two lots. Only then will you realise how much live results deviate from your backtest. Then work on your execution logic to make it more robust.
Go live. Once you are done with one or two months of forward testing, do not put in all your capital straight away. Instead, trade with just one lot for 100 days. Our goal is to be a profitable trader in the long run, not immediately. So first we need to follow a process.
Only when there is a process will there be progress. Keep an Excel sheet and add a date column. Next to it, enter +1 if you followed the rules of the system and -2 if you overrode the system. After 100 days, check the total.
Only when there is a process will there be progress.
If it's greater than 90, you are really a disciplined trader, and then you can increase your lot size. If your score is less than 90, never think of increasing your capital until you are disciplined enough.
If you keep these little things in mind when choosing a trading system or developing your own, it will definitely help you become a consistently profitable trader.
I first wrote this as a thread on X. Follow me there for new ones.